{
 "$schema": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/api/schemas/validation.schema.json",
 "schema_version": "2.6.0",
 "data_version": "7ee0afb7cec8197e7edde0e7c282c8e6e9670b7cef003e6aa218c5a536817f48",
 "license": "CC-BY-4.0",
 "case": "B",
 "title": "Case B — 1:4:4 slab",
 "status": "scored",
 "status_meaning": {
  "scored": "a validation run exists and its scores are in cases/{id}/validation.json",
  "running": "the solve is in progress; no scores yet",
  "pending": "not run yet",
  "not comparable": "the engine cannot produce the measured quantity at the measured location: OpenLB at 2 m on Cases C to E, where its empty-domain control misses the bar; the measurement behind it is on the Validation page"
 },
 "engines": [
  {
   "engine": "openfoam12-realizableKE",
   "status": "scored"
  },
  {
   "engine": "openlb",
   "status": "scored"
  },
  {
   "engine": "fluidx3d",
   "status": "scored"
  },
  {
   "engine": "ml-surrogate",
   "status": "scored"
  }
 ],
 "results": [
  {
   "run_id": "B.openfoam12-realizableKE",
   "engine": "openfoam12-realizableKE",
   "configuration": null,
   "solver": "realizableKE",
   "numerics_level": 3,
   "scale": 100,
   "solved_time": 3000,
   "iterations": null,
   "points_measured": 224,
   "lateral_sign_applied_in_fixture": -1,
   "recirculation_Lr_over_H": 3.2656362872742553,
   "quantity": null,
   "normalisation": "velocities by U_H, k by U_H^2 (the benchmark's own convention; Case E by U at 15.9 m, as it is published); hit rate D = 0.25, W = 0.05 in those units",
   "notes": [],
   "metric_meaning": {
    "Count": "number of measured points scored",
    "MeanObserved": "mean of the measured, normalised quantity",
    "MeanPredicted": "mean of the modelled, normalised quantity",
    "Fb": "fractional bias, 2 (mean_obs - mean_pred) / (mean_obs + mean_pred); positive = model low",
    "Nmse": "normalised mean square error",
    "Nad": "normalised absolute difference",
    "Fac2": "fraction of points within a factor of two (harsh near zero for sign-changing V and W)",
    "HitRate": "fraction of points within D = 0.25 relative or W = 0.05 U_H absolute",
    "Mg": "geometric mean bias",
    "Vg": "geometric variance",
    "GeometricPairs": "pairs with both values positive (used for Mg/Vg)",
    "R": "Pearson correlation coefficient",
    "null": "a metric that is undefined for the data (for example Mg and Vg when no pair has both values positive; Fb, Nmse and Nad of a signed velocity component of Case H or I whose observed and predicted means are not both positive)"
   },
   "headline": {
    "U": "velocity.U",
    "V": "velocity.V",
    "W": "velocity.W",
    "k": "k"
   },
   "scores": {
    "velocity.U": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": 0.3766289902869388,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.2960628391917841,
     "Fb": 0.23953360978856061,
     "Nmse": 0.20302931896841878,
     "Nad": 0.17102623037934778,
     "Fac2": 0.7008928571428571,
     "HitRate": 0.5625,
     "Mg": 1.2615189383876326,
     "Vg": 1.3760760064453128,
     "GeometricPairs": 142,
     "R": 0.9592051445848486
    },
    "velocity.V": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": -0.08283585204976207,
     "MeanPredicted": -0.056965347645487184,
     "Fb": 0.3701041830924148,
     "Nmse": 1.1007225641123684,
     "Nad": -0.37842506061923287,
     "Fac2": 0.28125,
     "HitRate": 0.6116071428571429,
     "Mg": 28.557820520342123,
     "Vg": 13810693243.325186,
     "GeometricPairs": 44,
     "R": 0.910002388064394
    },
    "velocity.W": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": 0.0425024700119674,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.03262169070579724,
     "Fb": 0.26305197187603707,
     "Nmse": 1.5241317431674757,
     "Nad": 0.4299690268812843,
     "Fac2": 0.5357142857142857,
     "HitRate": 0.8080357142857143,
     "Mg": 1.348168531844778,
     "Vg": 4.83146618469366,
     "GeometricPairs": 112,
     "R": 0.9290326152945579
    },
    "k": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": 0.05192140109788863,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.03240690107177359,
     "Fb": 0.462822078093149,
     "Nmse": 0.5505391703302587,
     "Nad": 0.29801121435007255,
     "Fac2": 0.5625,
     "HitRate": 0.22321428571428573,
     "Mg": 1.6988568353988318,
     "Vg": 1.978663266843241,
     "GeometricPairs": 224,
     "R": 0.39882335305432254
    }
   },
   "figures": [
    {
     "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/assets/figures/case-b-layout.png",
     "caption": "Case B, measurement lines and planes: A vertical profiles, y/H = 0; B plane z/H = 0.0625. Positions in multiples of H."
    },
    {
     "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/assets/figures/case-b-openfoam-agreement.png",
     "caption": "Case B, OpenFOAM 12 (realizable k-ε): measured against modelled U, V, W and k at every measured point, normalised by U_H, with the 1:1 line and the factor-of-two band. Dots take the colour of the line or plane they were measured on: the letters and colours of the layout figure of the case."
    },
    {
     "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/assets/figures/case-b-openfoam-profiles.png",
     "caption": "Case B, OpenFOAM 12: centre-plane vertical profiles of U/U_H at the measurement stations, measured points against the modelled line."
    }
   ],
   "pairs": {
    "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/api/cases/B/pairs/openfoam12-realizableKE.csv?v=9f7c10ff5544",
    "path": "cases/B/pairs/openfoam12-realizableKE.csv",
    "media_type": "text/csv",
    "bytes": 32157,
    "sha256": "9f7c10ff554477ffcfdc7e5717b2c7afbe2c0eb58cf0883d79bd202ce96126d7"
   },
   "pairs_columns": "point_id; x, y, z in m (case frame); U, V, W measured (_meas) and modelled (_model), each divided by U_H; V in the unified sign (positive toward +y)",
   "reproduce": "Eddy3D fixture TestAijCaseBContainerE2E; figures validation/plot_cases_ab_openfoam.py",
   "source_file": "validation/results/caseB_openfoam12_realizableKE.json",
   "source_url": "https://github.com/Eddy3D-Dev/AIJ-Data-Validation/blob/main/validation/results/caseB_openfoam12_realizableKE.json",
   "cite": "Kikumoto, H., Okaze, T., Yoshie, R., Tachibana, T., Ishihara, T., Nonomura, Y., Kiyota, N., Kondo, H., Mochida, A., Tominaga, Y. (2026). Comprehensive Experimental Database for Validating CFD Simulations in Urban Wind Environment: Benchmark Cases Curated by the Architectural Institute of Japan. Japan Architectural Review 9(1), e70083. https://doi.org/10.1002/2475-8876.70083"
  },
  {
   "run_id": "B.openlb",
   "engine": "openlb",
   "configuration": null,
   "solver": null,
   "numerics_level": null,
   "scale": 100,
   "solved_time": null,
   "iterations": null,
   "points_measured": 224,
   "lateral_sign_applied_in_fixture": -1,
   "recirculation_Lr_over_H": 2.633166773476624,
   "quantity": null,
   "normalisation": "velocities by U_H, k by U_H^2 (the benchmark's own convention; Case E by U at 15.9 m, as it is published); hit rate D = 0.25, W = 0.05 in those units",
   "notes": [],
   "metric_meaning": {
    "Count": "number of measured points scored",
    "MeanObserved": "mean of the measured, normalised quantity",
    "MeanPredicted": "mean of the modelled, normalised quantity",
    "Fb": "fractional bias, 2 (mean_obs - mean_pred) / (mean_obs + mean_pred); positive = model low",
    "Nmse": "normalised mean square error",
    "Nad": "normalised absolute difference",
    "Fac2": "fraction of points within a factor of two (harsh near zero for sign-changing V and W)",
    "HitRate": "fraction of points within D = 0.25 relative or W = 0.05 U_H absolute",
    "Mg": "geometric mean bias",
    "Vg": "geometric variance",
    "GeometricPairs": "pairs with both values positive (used for Mg/Vg)",
    "R": "Pearson correlation coefficient",
    "null": "a metric that is undefined for the data (for example Mg and Vg when no pair has both values positive; Fb, Nmse and Nad of a signed velocity component of Case H or I whose observed and predicted means are not both positive)"
   },
   "headline": {
    "U": "velocity.U",
    "U, points ≥ 2 dx": "velocity.U.aboveTwoCells",
    "V": "velocity.V",
    "W": "velocity.W",
    "k (resolved)": "k.resolved",
    "V, lateral sign flipped (control)": "control.V.lateralSignFlipped"
   },
   "scores": {
    "approachProfile.inflowVsMeasured": {
     "Count": 12,
     "MeanObserved": 0.9760536398467431,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.88539601680624,
     "Fb": 0.09740539876164239,
     "Nmse": 0.018350782150436756,
     "Nad": 0.05133993939802162,
     "Fac2": 1,
     "HitRate": 0.9166666666666666,
     "Mg": 1.1176662619671534,
     "Vg": 1.0306221115242802,
     "GeometricPairs": 12,
     "R": 0.9666047940953147
    },
    "approachProfile.solvedVsMeasured": {
     "Count": 12,
     "MeanObserved": 0.9760536398467431,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.8258757658829681,
     "Fb": 0.16668563539309006,
     "Nmse": 0.0591240186817257,
     "Nad": 0.09231593853866969,
     "Fac2": 0.8333333333333334,
     "HitRate": 0.75,
     "Mg": 1.3842689628480802,
     "Vg": 1.4174834721865484,
     "GeometricPairs": 12,
     "R": 0.931187599766342
    },
    "velocity.U": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": 0.3766289902869388,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.301967740297184,
     "Fb": 0.22004600560184803,
     "Nmse": 0.5306279297933821,
     "Nad": 0.29453140406838896,
     "Fac2": 0.42410714285714285,
     "HitRate": 0.2767857142857143,
     "Mg": 1.631915087591006,
     "Vg": 2.839353896879461,
     "GeometricPairs": 149,
     "R": 0.8488393598070382
    },
    "velocity.V": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": -0.08283585204976207,
     "MeanPredicted": -0.025935880326601685,
     "Fb": 1.0462271856860639,
     "Nmse": 5.248526140442946,
     "Nad": -0.6463976671444265,
     "Fac2": 0.21428571428571427,
     "HitRate": 0.59375,
     "Mg": 2.0958970809117856,
     "Vg": 10.670154175494291,
     "GeometricPairs": 57,
     "R": 0.8690462851081936
    },
    "velocity.W": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": 0.0425024700119674,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.024192704796112373,
     "Fb": 0.5490581670575934,
     "Nmse": 5.604156996731412,
     "Nad": 0.7416401484713603,
     "Fac2": 0.32142857142857145,
     "HitRate": 0.7008928571428571,
     "Mg": 1.7044783454040102,
     "Vg": 9.96865447920694,
     "GeometricPairs": 102,
     "R": 0.7960357059619825
    },
    "rms.u": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": 0.21030668787667514,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.05974348164752357,
     "Fb": 1.11507581346406,
     "Nmse": 2.1563098614183867,
     "Nad": 0.5628746021367588,
     "Fac2": 0.13392857142857142,
     "HitRate": 0.04017857142857143,
     "Mg": 4.54701901273993,
     "Vg": 15.042384332532514,
     "GeometricPairs": 224,
     "R": 0.32936646131751796
    },
    "rms.v": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": 0.18592909607926836,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.03861191549182262,
     "Fb": 1.3121627942858385,
     "Nmse": 3.3366150913448536,
     "Nad": 0.6560813971429194,
     "Fac2": 0.008928571428571428,
     "HitRate": 0,
     "Mg": 6.101070264778556,
     "Vg": 39.656290927919784,
     "GeometricPairs": 224,
     "R": 0.59205828871875
    },
    "rms.w": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": 0.12429442865161876,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.05151456656492929,
     "Fb": 0.8279424155407384,
     "Nmse": 1.0624538408775974,
     "Nad": 0.4285843550315497,
     "Fac2": 0.20535714285714285,
     "HitRate": 0.07142857142857142,
     "Mg": 3.0287856454706574,
     "Vg": 4.39460289072884,
     "GeometricPairs": 224,
     "R": 0.6898215184686439
    },
    "k.resolved": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": 0.05192140109788863,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.006866415900740086,
     "Fb": 1.5328000765260426,
     "Nmse": 6.910095821770621,
     "Nad": 0.7664000382630216,
     "Fac2": 0.049107142857142856,
     "HitRate": 0.017857142857142856,
     "Mg": 15.060367429715932,
     "Vg": 3936.060427317771,
     "GeometricPairs": 224,
     "R": 0.4488915842600138
    },
    "velocity.U.aboveTwoCells": {
     "Count": 95,
     "MeanObserved": 0.5406851436012592,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.5412937265163492,
     "Fb": -0.0011249441775584331,
     "Nmse": 0.1252509763110189,
     "Nad": 0.13425074474603138,
     "Fac2": 0.6105263157894737,
     "HitRate": 0.5263157894736842,
     "Mg": 1.1556727714982709,
     "Vg": 1.3622855544152088,
     "GeometricPairs": 65,
     "R": 0.9294982497160469
    },
    "velocity.V.aboveTwoCells": {
     "Count": 95,
     "MeanObserved": -0.01662513970490223,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.002609398445907286,
     "Fb": 2.74470508485811,
     "Nmse": -40.927079364581644,
     "Nad": -2.166258358659073,
     "Fac2": 0.05263157894736842,
     "HitRate": 0.8105263157894737,
     "Mg": 2.763206469722076,
     "Vg": 19.01075277600892,
     "GeometricPairs": 29,
     "R": 0.5859242577315255
    },
    "velocity.W.aboveTwoCells": {
     "Count": 95,
     "MeanObserved": 0.11213715176310149,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.06658733815603886,
     "Fb": 0.5097210083259497,
     "Nmse": 1.634301352053413,
     "Nad": 0.46597634975361574,
     "Fac2": 0.4631578947368421,
     "HitRate": 0.4631578947368421,
     "Mg": 1.5429969685900808,
     "Vg": 6.623549753559801,
     "GeometricPairs": 60,
     "R": 0.7498021176434413
    },
    "k.resolved.aboveTwoCells": {
     "Count": 95,
     "MeanObserved": 0.055680904609688414,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.012836406165893472,
     "Fb": 1.2506182148369958,
     "Nmse": 3.472161109359036,
     "Nad": 0.6253091074184981,
     "Fac2": 0.11578947368421053,
     "HitRate": 0.042105263157894736,
     "Mg": 8.011973314150286,
     "Vg": 173.4779326118934,
     "GeometricPairs": 95,
     "R": 0.5078131180585612
    },
    "region.wake.U": {
     "Count": 120,
     "MeanObserved": 0.17108253782713156,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.0808531738599584,
     "Fb": 0.7162887973519224,
     "Nmse": 5.344659610046248,
     "Nad": 0.9133145237798518,
     "Fac2": 0.225,
     "HitRate": 0.11666666666666667,
     "Mg": 2.1800098280087177,
     "Vg": 7.376291423734374,
     "GeometricPairs": 61,
     "R": 0.6433588419811869
    },
    "region.wake.k.resolved": {
     "Count": 120,
     "MeanObserved": 0.057661603641974056,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.006776188122386167,
     "Fb": 1.579365590480461,
     "Nmse": 7.406250174943314,
     "Nad": 0.7896827952402311,
     "Fac2": 0.041666666666666664,
     "HitRate": 0.008333333333333333,
     "Mg": 17.270486350605726,
     "Vg": 9049.14858308626,
     "GeometricPairs": 120,
     "R": 0.46253044690590817
    },
    "region.wake.U.aboveTwoCells": {
     "Count": 30,
     "MeanObserved": 0.005954932138450549,
     "MeanPredicted": -0.044577835185401656,
     "Fb": -2.616725483448156,
     "Nmse": -141.7803356327098,
     "Nad": -4.415121370552365,
     "Fac2": 0.2,
     "HitRate": 0.13333333333333333,
     "Mg": 2.1620782466253163,
     "Vg": 1.8285137507802902,
     "GeometricPairs": 5,
     "R": 0.6174265772079962
    },
    "region.aboveRoof.U": {
     "Count": 60,
     "MeanObserved": 0.8177998571335799,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.841208169082408,
     "Fb": -0.028219648824990715,
     "Nmse": 0.05581533690896943,
     "Nad": 0.08248853833699159,
     "Fac2": 0.8,
     "HitRate": 0.7166666666666667,
     "Mg": 1.0864498438445034,
     "Vg": 1.2954475735134279,
     "GeometricPairs": 55,
     "R": 0.8709326892990407
    },
    "region.aboveRoof.k.resolved": {
     "Count": 60,
     "MeanObserved": 0.05058318397488296,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.010364786474672734,
     "Fb": 1.3197616656816311,
     "Nmse": 4.313937673477358,
     "Nad": 0.6598808328408156,
     "Fac2": 0.1,
     "HitRate": 0.05,
     "Mg": 10.337523521002652,
     "Vg": 557.8803849126691,
     "GeometricPairs": 60,
     "R": 0.48818912445774
    },
    "region.aboveRoof.U.aboveTwoCells": {
     "Count": 60,
     "MeanObserved": 0.8177998571335799,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.841208169082408,
     "Fb": -0.028219648824990715,
     "Nmse": 0.05581533690896943,
     "Nad": 0.08248853833699159,
     "Fac2": 0.8,
     "HitRate": 0.7166666666666667,
     "Mg": 1.0864498438445034,
     "Vg": 1.2954475735134279,
     "GeometricPairs": 55,
     "R": 0.8709326892990407
    },
    "region.rest.U": {
     "Count": 44,
     "MeanObserved": 0.33561358765917504,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.16967960950976743,
     "Fb": 0.6567829493019212,
     "Nmse": 0.934884185432374,
     "Nad": 0.40246248902705484,
     "Fac2": 0.45454545454545453,
     "HitRate": 0.11363636363636363,
     "Mg": 1.8823927598551247,
     "Vg": 1.79805474687921,
     "GeometricPairs": 33,
     "R": 0.8262795928523669
    },
    "region.rest.k.resolved": {
     "Count": 44,
     "MeanObserved": 0.038091144781754335,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.0023419863317971626,
     "Fb": 1.7683101686861715,
     "Nmse": 17.546362815534728,
     "Nad": 0.8841550843430861,
     "Fac2": 0,
     "HitRate": 0,
     "Mg": 17.31775348802143,
     "Vg": 5835.807393956601,
     "GeometricPairs": 44,
     "R": -0.10426499237522803
    },
    "region.rest.U.aboveTwoCells": {
     "Count": 5,
     "MeanObserved": 0.42368984999025916,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.4575497859341516,
     "Fb": -0.07684614845625665,
     "Nmse": 0.05103756728425319,
     "Nad": 0.10727424801804268,
     "Fac2": 0.8,
     "HitRate": 0.6,
     "Mg": 1.2186403305759048,
     "Vg": 1.7651006591895282,
     "GeometricPairs": 5,
     "R": 0.9608994534376295
    },
    "control.V.lateralSignFlipped": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": 0.08283585204976207,
     "MeanPredicted": -0.025935880326601685,
     "Fb": 3.8232613859837703,
     "Nmse": -35.59396439713143,
     "Nad": 2.6413625857424563,
     "Fac2": 0.17857142857142858,
     "HitRate": 0.5089285714285714,
     "Mg": 2.736864227308537,
     "Vg": 21.623962371474605,
     "GeometricPairs": 74,
     "R": -0.8690462851081936
    },
    "control.U.permuted": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": 0.3766289902869388,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.3019677402971844,
     "Fb": 0.22004600560184676,
     "Nmse": 2.948230483192291,
     "Nad": 0.6961498259913604,
     "Fac2": 0.23214285714285715,
     "HitRate": 0.11607142857142858,
     "Mg": 1.9692316105944543,
     "Vg": 45.11724677386381,
     "GeometricPairs": 127,
     "R": 0.08491895020282955
    },
    "shift.U.-0.5H": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": 0.3766289902869388,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.3082780579112056,
     "Fb": 0.199591849888393,
     "Nmse": 0.8134473445581704,
     "Nad": 0.363600585673016,
     "Fac2": 0.3705357142857143,
     "HitRate": 0.23660714285714285,
     "Mg": 1.585308088696255,
     "Vg": 2.668864484033988,
     "GeometricPairs": 144,
     "R": 0.7601161071744863
    },
    "shift.U.aboveTwoCells.-0.5H": {
     "Count": 95,
     "MeanObserved": 0.5406851436012592,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.5924276714187025,
     "Fb": -0.09132811337330385,
     "Nmse": 0.3157846813203947,
     "Nad": 0.21251595591013347,
     "Fac2": 0.5473684210526316,
     "HitRate": 0.42105263157894735,
     "Mg": 0.9958385460097917,
     "Vg": 1.5985331338413504,
     "GeometricPairs": 61,
     "R": 0.8057797202670448
    },
    "shift.U.-0.25H": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": 0.3766289902869388,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.30253044262146694,
     "Fb": 0.2182066362478546,
     "Nmse": 0.7083523244318014,
     "Nad": 0.3389237607073972,
     "Fac2": 0.36160714285714285,
     "HitRate": 0.26339285714285715,
     "Mg": 1.6180089386323835,
     "Vg": 2.94229134294426,
     "GeometricPairs": 146,
     "R": 0.7971919848039091
    },
    "shift.U.aboveTwoCells.-0.25H": {
     "Count": 95,
     "MeanObserved": 0.5406851436012592,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.5652088888816108,
     "Fb": -0.04435098582690197,
     "Nmse": 0.23488344371269126,
     "Nad": 0.1768197021096454,
     "Fac2": 0.5578947368421052,
     "HitRate": 0.4631578947368421,
     "Mg": 1.1604828399953009,
     "Vg": 1.9347786759046606,
     "GeometricPairs": 64,
     "R": 0.8622585147560005
    },
    "shift.U.+0.25H": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": 0.3766289902869388,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.29846293553765696,
     "Fb": 0.23157158828053045,
     "Nmse": 0.49967150685310424,
     "Nad": 0.2831445430012206,
     "Fac2": 0.42857142857142855,
     "HitRate": 0.29910714285714285,
     "Mg": 1.814574945213023,
     "Vg": 4.689930195210392,
     "GeometricPairs": 154,
     "R": 0.8592290738349917
    },
    "shift.U.aboveTwoCells.+0.25H": {
     "Count": 95,
     "MeanObserved": 0.5406851436012592,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.5047494388675381,
     "Fb": 0.06874787832034178,
     "Nmse": 0.0838317112345372,
     "Nad": 0.11301308460648145,
     "Fac2": 0.6736842105263158,
     "HitRate": 0.5473684210526316,
     "Mg": 1.4129868534702872,
     "Vg": 2.9323075734582646,
     "GeometricPairs": 65,
     "R": 0.9595310077343797
    },
    "shift.U.+0.5H": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": 0.3766289902869388,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.28699798927568926,
     "Fb": 0.27012464463190455,
     "Nmse": 0.547623655829157,
     "Nad": 0.2857969367600624,
     "Fac2": 0.41964285714285715,
     "HitRate": 0.3392857142857143,
     "Mg": 1.8725276980085375,
     "Vg": 5.080589059008849,
     "GeometricPairs": 156,
     "R": 0.8550318403768112
    },
    "shift.U.aboveTwoCells.+0.5H": {
     "Count": 95,
     "MeanObserved": 0.5406851436012592,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.4783288404838612,
     "Fb": 0.1223855689740745,
     "Nmse": 0.09376587016556834,
     "Nad": 0.10726499864983258,
     "Fac2": 0.6947368421052632,
     "HitRate": 0.6,
     "Mg": 1.4045226703791187,
     "Vg": 2.076756086216546,
     "GeometricPairs": 67,
     "R": 0.9611617974116
    }
   },
   "figures": [
    {
     "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/assets/figures/case-b-engine-comparison.png",
     "caption": "Case B, every engine on the same points: measured against modelled U/U_H and V/U_H, one row per engine (OpenFOAM 12; OpenLB at dx = 1.6 m; FluidX3D at H/64). FluidX3D is scored on the filled points, the heights where its empty-domain control holds the imposed log law; the hollow points near the ground are excluded."
    }
   ],
   "pairs": {
    "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/api/cases/B/pairs/openlb.csv?v=bdd88dbe936b",
    "path": "cases/B/pairs/openlb.csv",
    "media_type": "text/csv",
    "bytes": 32036,
    "sha256": "bdd88dbe936b600682bc1a2f25e9b363993d3f8f088551697de5e7ab4ee89b98"
   },
   "pairs_columns": "point_id; x, y, z in m (case frame); U, V, W measured (_meas) and modelled (_model), each divided by U_H; V in the unified sign (positive toward +y)",
   "reproduce": "Eddy3D fixture TestAijCaseBOpenLbContainerE2E (OpenLB eddy3dWind, image 1.9.3-r6, CPU build, dx = 1.6 m); figure validation/plot_cases_ab_engines.py",
   "source_file": "validation/results/caseB_openlb.json",
   "source_url": "https://github.com/Eddy3D-Dev/AIJ-Data-Validation/blob/main/validation/results/caseB_openlb.json",
   "cite": "Kikumoto, H., Okaze, T., Yoshie, R., Tachibana, T., Ishihara, T., Nonomura, Y., Kiyota, N., Kondo, H., Mochida, A., Tominaga, Y. (2026). Comprehensive Experimental Database for Validating CFD Simulations in Urban Wind Environment: Benchmark Cases Curated by the Architectural Institute of Japan. Japan Architectural Review 9(1), e70083. https://doi.org/10.1002/2475-8876.70083"
  },
  {
   "run_id": "B.fluidx3d",
   "engine": "fluidx3d",
   "configuration": null,
   "solver": "FluidX3D 8986874e626e (D3Q19 SRT + Smagorinsky, FP16S, TYPE_E log-law faces, bounce-back ground)",
   "numerics_level": null,
   "scale": "model (1:1), H = 0.2 m, identity frame: U=U_x, V=U_y, W=U_z",
   "solved_time": null,
   "iterations": null,
   "points_measured": 224,
   "lateral_sign_applied_in_fixture": -1,
   "recirculation_Lr_over_H": 2.6343469116928886,
   "quantity": null,
   "normalisation": "velocities by U_H, k by U_H^2 (the benchmark's own convention; Case E by U at 15.9 m, as it is published); hit rate D = 0.25, W = 0.05 in those units",
   "notes": [],
   "metric_meaning": {
    "Count": "number of measured points scored",
    "MeanObserved": "mean of the measured, normalised quantity",
    "MeanPredicted": "mean of the modelled, normalised quantity",
    "Fb": "fractional bias, 2 (mean_obs - mean_pred) / (mean_obs + mean_pred); positive = model low",
    "Nmse": "normalised mean square error",
    "Nad": "normalised absolute difference",
    "Fac2": "fraction of points within a factor of two (harsh near zero for sign-changing V and W)",
    "HitRate": "fraction of points within D = 0.25 relative or W = 0.05 U_H absolute",
    "Mg": "geometric mean bias",
    "Vg": "geometric variance",
    "GeometricPairs": "pairs with both values positive (used for Mg/Vg)",
    "R": "Pearson correlation coefficient",
    "null": "a metric that is undefined for the data (for example Mg and Vg when no pair has both values positive; Fb, Nmse and Nad of a signed velocity component of Case H or I whose observed and predicted means are not both positive)"
   },
   "headline": {
    "U, comparable heights": "velocity.U.comparable",
    "W, comparable heights": "velocity.W.comparable",
    "U, all points": "velocity.U.all",
    "U, approach flow alone (control)": "negativeControl.noBuilding.components.U.control"
   },
   "scores": {
    "velocity.U.all": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": 0.3766289902869388,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.31692712230324876,
     "Fb": 0.1721616085560103,
     "Nmse": 0.3798595588770529,
     "Nad": 0.24294762983289397,
     "Fac2": 0.6383928571428571,
     "HitRate": 0.4107142857142857,
     "Mg": 1.1280278671778057,
     "Vg": 1.645415281437531,
     "GeometricPairs": 145,
     "R": 0.9054779176869349
    },
    "velocity.V.all": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": -0.08283585204976207,
     "MeanPredicted": -0.061229290210060856,
     "Fb": 0.2999554437774207,
     "Nmse": 1.773378183640003,
     "Nad": -0.4861736056429089,
     "Fac2": 0.2767857142857143,
     "HitRate": 0.5446428571428571,
     "Mg": 1.6636706261356144,
     "Vg": 101.65615645092355,
     "GeometricPairs": 48,
     "R": 0.8931364742865375
    },
    "velocity.W.all": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": 0.0425024700119674,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.0317328938562042,
     "Fb": 0.29014678704580715,
     "Nmse": 3.8078780228405877,
     "Nad": 0.7564564854395088,
     "Fac2": 0.32142857142857145,
     "HitRate": 0.5267857142857143,
     "Mg": 1.2325514605352323,
     "Vg": 15.219042755567031,
     "GeometricPairs": 103,
     "R": 0.8373377166452571
    },
    "velocity.U.comparable": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": 0.5888413651417742,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.4535821753760864,
     "Fb": 0.2595090853349168,
     "Nmse": 0.2080149002588724,
     "Nad": 0.15999921463865083,
     "Fac2": 0.6363636363636364,
     "HitRate": 0.5681818181818182,
     "Mg": 1.3332895727521348,
     "Vg": 1.5980067426367395,
     "GeometricPairs": 57,
     "R": 0.9465986290410954
    },
    "velocity.V.comparable": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": -0.013136921523829764,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.006319145421615921,
     "Fb": 5.7074525926798865,
     "Nmse": -22.60349865237665,
     "Nad": -4.607264531703129,
     "Fac2": 0.10227272727272728,
     "HitRate": 0.7840909090909091,
     "Mg": 4.369427490006514,
     "Vg": 1031.7981876940405,
     "GeometricPairs": 22,
     "R": 0.03754317284208111
    },
    "velocity.W.comparable": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": 0.11702796521615925,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.1044221917891121,
     "Fb": 0.11384750047160347,
     "Nmse": 0.6036339915560935,
     "Nad": 0.3352135429832316,
     "Fac2": 0.4772727272727273,
     "HitRate": 0.3181818181818182,
     "Mg": 1.1736821851051105,
     "Vg": 2.858249253549767,
     "GeometricPairs": 59,
     "R": 0.8451076183090223
    },
    "velocity.U.excluded": {
     "Count": 136,
     "MeanObserved": 0.23931510067498654,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.22850326443258884,
     "Fb": 0.04622236769140737,
     "Nmse": 0.708260261563057,
     "Nad": 0.36254422066432723,
     "Fac2": 0.6397058823529411,
     "HitRate": 0.3088235294117647,
     "Mg": 1.0122593904187982,
     "Vg": 1.6768710503517341,
     "GeometricPairs": 88,
     "R": 0.8618389211172498
    },
    "velocity.V.excluded": {
     "Count": 136,
     "MeanObserved": -0.12793516003713004,
     "MeanPredicted": -0.10493710150114584,
     "Fb": 0.19751651299357645,
     "Nmse": 1.0130533670716448,
     "Nad": -0.4081041889601288,
     "Fac2": 0.3897058823529412,
     "HitRate": 0.3897058823529412,
     "Mg": 0.7348972991046476,
     "Vg": 14.305820626242589,
     "GeometricPairs": 26,
     "R": 0.8965073023695301
    },
    "velocity.W.excluded": {
     "Count": 136,
     "MeanObserved": -0.00571990923780383,
     "MeanPredicted": -0.01530135774744199,
     "Fb": -0.9115957203115383,
     "Nmse": 42.11320327080803,
     "Nad": -2.114942257634418,
     "Fac2": 0.22058823529411764,
     "HitRate": 0.6617647058823529,
     "Mg": 1.3161502703582235,
     "Vg": 143.30868062363436,
     "GeometricPairs": 44,
     "R": 0.6672203288720936
    },
    "negativeControl.wrongLateralSign.components.U.control": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": 0.5888413651417742,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.4535821753760864,
     "Fb": 0.2595090853349168,
     "Nmse": 0.2080149002588724,
     "Nad": 0.15999921463865083,
     "Fac2": 0.6363636363636364,
     "HitRate": 0.5681818181818182,
     "Mg": 1.3332895727521348,
     "Vg": 1.5980067426367395,
     "GeometricPairs": 57,
     "R": 0.9465986290410954
    },
    "negativeControl.wrongLateralSign.components.U.solved": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": 0.5888413651417742,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.4535821753760864,
     "Fb": 0.2595090853349168,
     "Nmse": 0.2080149002588724,
     "Nad": 0.15999921463865083,
     "Fac2": 0.6363636363636364,
     "HitRate": 0.5681818181818182,
     "Mg": 1.3332895727521348,
     "Vg": 1.5980067426367395,
     "GeometricPairs": 57,
     "R": 0.9465986290410954
    },
    "negativeControl.wrongLateralSign.components.V.control": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": 0.013136921523829764,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.006319145421615921,
     "Fb": 0.7008380595452013,
     "Nmse": 19.272308100286715,
     "Nad": 1.4883199241654168,
     "Fac2": 0.13636363636363635,
     "HitRate": 0.7954545454545454,
     "Mg": 3.732768276684996,
     "Vg": 38.25416386041205,
     "GeometricPairs": 48,
     "R": -0.03754317284208111
    },
    "negativeControl.wrongLateralSign.components.V.solved": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": -0.013136921523829764,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.006319145421615921,
     "Fb": 5.7074525926798865,
     "Nmse": -22.60349865237665,
     "Nad": -4.607264531703129,
     "Fac2": 0.10227272727272728,
     "HitRate": 0.7840909090909091,
     "Mg": 4.369427490006514,
     "Vg": 1031.7981876940405,
     "GeometricPairs": 22,
     "R": 0.03754317284208111
    },
    "negativeControl.wrongLateralSign.components.W.control": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": 0.11702796521615925,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.1044221917891121,
     "Fb": 0.11384750047160347,
     "Nmse": 0.6036339915560935,
     "Nad": 0.3352135429832316,
     "Fac2": 0.4772727272727273,
     "HitRate": 0.3181818181818182,
     "Mg": 1.1736821851051105,
     "Vg": 2.858249253549767,
     "GeometricPairs": 59,
     "R": 0.8451076183090223
    },
    "negativeControl.wrongLateralSign.components.W.solved": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": 0.11702796521615925,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.1044221917891121,
     "Fb": 0.11384750047160347,
     "Nmse": 0.6036339915560935,
     "Nad": 0.3352135429832316,
     "Fac2": 0.4772727272727273,
     "HitRate": 0.3181818181818182,
     "Mg": 1.1736821851051105,
     "Vg": 2.858249253549767,
     "GeometricPairs": 59,
     "R": 0.8451076183090223
    },
    "negativeControl.streamwiseMirror.components.U.control": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": 0.5888413651417742,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.8343383679113777,
     "Fb": -0.34499789038302003,
     "Nmse": 0.5552614056732248,
     "Nad": 0.28938837319817734,
     "Fac2": 0.5113636363636364,
     "HitRate": 0.42045454545454547,
     "Mg": 0.6417413438347143,
     "Vg": 2.487595435175171,
     "GeometricPairs": 64,
     "R": 0.43100038464649737
    },
    "negativeControl.streamwiseMirror.components.U.solved": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": 0.5888413651417742,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.4535821753760864,
     "Fb": 0.2595090853349168,
     "Nmse": 0.2080149002588724,
     "Nad": 0.15999921463865083,
     "Fac2": 0.6363636363636364,
     "HitRate": 0.5681818181818182,
     "Mg": 1.3332895727521348,
     "Vg": 1.5980067426367395,
     "GeometricPairs": 57,
     "R": 0.9465986290410954
    },
    "negativeControl.streamwiseMirror.components.V.control": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": -0.013136921523829764,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.0020764560803759355,
     "Fb": 2.750947088435557,
     "Nmse": -59.38901773599293,
     "Nad": -2.7280011956240346,
     "Fac2": 0.045454545454545456,
     "HitRate": 0.8068181818181818,
     "Mg": 14.44555133262459,
     "Vg": 112720.95569904707,
     "GeometricPairs": 17,
     "R": 0.17103853809967834
    },
    "negativeControl.streamwiseMirror.components.V.solved": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": -0.013136921523829764,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.006319145421615921,
     "Fb": 5.7074525926798865,
     "Nmse": -22.60349865237665,
     "Nad": -4.607264531703129,
     "Fac2": 0.10227272727272728,
     "HitRate": 0.7840909090909091,
     "Mg": 4.369427490006514,
     "Vg": 1031.7981876940405,
     "GeometricPairs": 22,
     "R": 0.03754317284208111
    },
    "negativeControl.streamwiseMirror.components.W.control": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": 0.11702796521615925,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.12517913793669,
     "Fb": -0.06730746220425085,
     "Nmse": 1.6855814022571158,
     "Nad": 0.43455508940070803,
     "Fac2": 0.4090909090909091,
     "HitRate": 0.3181818181818182,
     "Mg": 1.0392908774378347,
     "Vg": 2.9176953296317767,
     "GeometricPairs": 57,
     "R": 0.44566435218417116
    },
    "negativeControl.streamwiseMirror.components.W.solved": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": 0.11702796521615925,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.1044221917891121,
     "Fb": 0.11384750047160347,
     "Nmse": 0.6036339915560935,
     "Nad": 0.3352135429832316,
     "Fac2": 0.4772727272727273,
     "HitRate": 0.3181818181818182,
     "Mg": 1.1736821851051105,
     "Vg": 2.858249253549767,
     "GeometricPairs": 59,
     "R": 0.8451076183090223
    },
    "negativeControl.noBuilding.components.U.control": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": 0.5888413651417742,
     "MeanPredicted": 1.025512021893917,
     "Fb": -0.5409852145867101,
     "Nmse": 0.6309469366705739,
     "Nad": 0.2925677802060514,
     "Fac2": 0.5568181818181818,
     "HitRate": 0.3977272727272727,
     "Mg": 0.5874654056045466,
     "Vg": 2.381025574073139,
     "GeometricPairs": 71,
     "R": 0.8068423911100763
    },
    "negativeControl.noBuilding.components.U.solved": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": 0.5888413651417742,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.4535821753760864,
     "Fb": 0.2595090853349168,
     "Nmse": 0.2080149002588724,
     "Nad": 0.15999921463865083,
     "Fac2": 0.6363636363636364,
     "HitRate": 0.5681818181818182,
     "Mg": 1.3332895727521348,
     "Vg": 1.5980067426367395,
     "GeometricPairs": 57,
     "R": 0.9465986290410954
    },
    "negativeControl.noBuilding.components.V.control": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": -0.013136921523829764,
     "MeanPredicted": -0.00081066819372127,
     "Fb": 1.7675101691007842,
     "Nmse": 147.39977621185577,
     "Nad": -2.0095489522933616,
     "Fac2": 0.011363636363636364,
     "HitRate": 0.8068181818181818,
     "Mg": 707.7097425053696,
     "Vg": 5.25199538528466e+18,
     "GeometricPairs": 2,
     "R": 0.21038889669709726
    },
    "negativeControl.noBuilding.components.V.solved": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": -0.013136921523829764,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.006319145421615921,
     "Fb": 5.7074525926798865,
     "Nmse": -22.60349865237665,
     "Nad": -4.607264531703129,
     "Fac2": 0.10227272727272728,
     "HitRate": 0.7840909090909091,
     "Mg": 4.369427490006514,
     "Vg": 1031.7981876940405,
     "GeometricPairs": 22,
     "R": 0.03754317284208111
    },
    "negativeControl.noBuilding.components.W.control": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": 0.11702796521615925,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.007296564546107339,
     "Fb": 1.765241354700964,
     "Nmse": 41.99830721292324,
     "Nad": 1.1252809567664637,
     "Fac2": 0.03409090909090909,
     "HitRate": 0.2840909090909091,
     "Mg": 17.66140699656026,
     "Vg": 9317.908302433798,
     "GeometricPairs": 60,
     "R": 0.48557941789010295
    },
    "negativeControl.noBuilding.components.W.solved": {
     "Count": 88,
     "MeanObserved": 0.11702796521615925,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.1044221917891121,
     "Fb": 0.11384750047160347,
     "Nmse": 0.6036339915560935,
     "Nad": 0.3352135429832316,
     "Fac2": 0.4772727272727273,
     "HitRate": 0.3181818181818182,
     "Mg": 1.1736821851051105,
     "Vg": 2.858249253549767,
     "GeometricPairs": 59,
     "R": 0.8451076183090223
    },
    "negativeControl.wrongLateralSign.discriminating.allPointsVote.withLateralSign": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": -0.08283585204976207,
     "MeanPredicted": -0.061229290210060856,
     "Fb": 0.2999554437774207,
     "Nmse": 1.773378183640003,
     "Nad": -0.4861736056429089,
     "Fac2": 0.2767857142857143,
     "HitRate": 0.5446428571428571,
     "Mg": 1.6636706261356144,
     "Vg": 101.65615645092355,
     "GeometricPairs": 48,
     "R": 0.8931364742865375
    },
    "negativeControl.wrongLateralSign.discriminating.allPointsVote.flipped": {
     "Count": 224,
     "MeanObserved": 0.08283585204976207,
     "MeanPredicted": -0.061229290210060856,
     "Fb": 13.335313904048245,
     "Nmse": -28.750402715944762,
     "Nad": 9.612111925179489,
     "Fac2": 0.14285714285714285,
     "HitRate": 0.45089285714285715,
     "Mg": 1.791210587923325,
     "Vg": 13.785945271021022,
     "GeometricPairs": 85,
     "R": -0.8931364742865375
    }
   },
   "figures": [
    {
     "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/assets/figures/case-b-engine-comparison.png",
     "caption": "Case B, every engine on the same points: measured against modelled U/U_H and V/U_H, one row per engine (OpenFOAM 12; OpenLB at dx = 1.6 m; FluidX3D at H/64). FluidX3D is scored on the filled points, the heights where its empty-domain control holds the imposed log law; the hollow points near the ground are excluded."
    }
   ],
   "pairs": {
    "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/api/cases/B/pairs/fluidx3d.csv?v=c4af803fd09e",
    "path": "cases/B/pairs/fluidx3d.csv",
    "media_type": "text/csv",
    "bytes": 31939,
    "sha256": "c4af803fd09e91d65f7853e5adfa9d912c2a8118662172ed5f9fc9449765255e"
   },
   "pairs_columns": "point_id; x, y, z in m (case frame); U, V, W measured (_meas) and modelled (_model), each divided by U_H; V in the unified sign (positive toward +y)",
   "reproduce": "Eddy3D fixture TestAijCaseBFluidX3DE2E (Eddy3DCli.Tests/Validation/TestAijVelocityFluidX3DE2E; FluidX3D GPU lattice Boltzmann, D3Q19 Smagorinsky LES, dx = H/64, 100 + 500 H/U_H spin-up + averaging, with an empty-domain control on the same lattice); figure validation/plot_cases_ab_engines.py",
   "source_file": "validation/results/caseB_fluidx3d.json",
   "source_url": "https://github.com/Eddy3D-Dev/AIJ-Data-Validation/blob/main/validation/results/caseB_fluidx3d.json",
   "cite": "Kikumoto, H., Okaze, T., Yoshie, R., Tachibana, T., Ishihara, T., Nonomura, Y., Kiyota, N., Kondo, H., Mochida, A., Tominaga, Y. (2026). Comprehensive Experimental Database for Validating CFD Simulations in Urban Wind Environment: Benchmark Cases Curated by the Architectural Institute of Japan. Japan Architectural Review 9(1), e70083. https://doi.org/10.1002/2475-8876.70083"
  },
  {
   "run_id": "B.ml-surrogate",
   "engine": "ml-surrogate",
   "configuration": null,
   "solver": "ML surrogate — Eddy3D Wind Predictor, Yel-2.0.onnx (1 output channel, |U_mean|/U_ref) on ONNX Runtime CPU",
   "numerics_level": null,
   "scale": 144,
   "solved_time": null,
   "iterations": null,
   "points_measured": 122,
   "lateral_sign_applied_in_fixture": null,
   "recirculation_Lr_over_H": null,
   "quantity": null,
   "normalisation": "velocities by U_H, k by U_H^2 (the benchmark's own convention; Case E by U at 15.9 m, as it is published); hit rate D = 0.25, W = 0.05 in those units",
   "notes": [],
   "metric_meaning": {
    "Count": "number of measured points scored",
    "MeanObserved": "mean of the measured, normalised quantity",
    "MeanPredicted": "mean of the modelled, normalised quantity",
    "Fb": "fractional bias, 2 (mean_obs - mean_pred) / (mean_obs + mean_pred); positive = model low",
    "Nmse": "normalised mean square error",
    "Nad": "normalised absolute difference",
    "Fac2": "fraction of points within a factor of two (harsh near zero for sign-changing V and W)",
    "HitRate": "fraction of points within D = 0.25 relative or W = 0.05 U_H absolute",
    "Mg": "geometric mean bias",
    "Vg": "geometric variance",
    "GeometricPairs": "pairs with both values positive (used for Mg/Vg)",
    "R": "Pearson correlation coefficient",
    "null": "a metric that is undefined for the data (for example Mg and Vg when no pair has both values positive; Fb, Nmse and Nad of a signed velocity component of Case H or I whose observed and predicted means are not both positive)"
   },
   "headline": {
    "|U| (z = H/16 plane)": "speed.vectorMagnitude",
    "|U|, lattice cut at ±250 m": "halfExtent250.forward",
    "wind reversed (control)": "negativeControl.reversedWind"
   },
   "scores": {
    "speed.vectorMagnitude": {
     "Count": 122,
     "MeanObserved": 0.43181001182262224,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.18056228027717783,
     "Fb": 0.8205718475077507,
     "Nmse": 1.8525030365418953,
     "Nad": 0.501199909029357,
     "Fac2": 0.36065573770491804,
     "HitRate": 0.1721311475409836,
     "Mg": 2.3999173698538603,
     "Vg": 9.74496324464555,
     "GeometricPairs": 117,
     "R": -0.23552778058356127
    },
    "speed.scalarRms": {
     "Count": 122,
     "MeanObserved": 0.5546386212046104,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.18056228027717783,
     "Fb": 1.0176166546408918,
     "Nmse": 1.9396043217341556,
     "Nad": 0.5197027060391161,
     "Fac2": 0.29508196721311475,
     "HitRate": 0.11475409836065574,
     "Mg": 3.601488899501991,
     "Vg": 12.390623688906997,
     "GeometricPairs": 117,
     "R": -0.20960276065942185
    },
    "speed.vectorMagnitude.noUrefConversion": {
     "Count": 122,
     "MeanObserved": 0.43181001182262224,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.22789293343444303,
     "Fb": 0.6182087858004611,
     "Nmse": 1.3717983850193323,
     "Nad": 0.45793217108447487,
     "Fac2": 0.39344262295081966,
     "HitRate": 0.18032786885245902,
     "Mg": 1.901483061572314,
     "Vg": 6.843805748348614,
     "GeometricPairs": 117,
     "R": -0.23552778058356122
    },
    "negativeControl.reversedWind": {
     "Count": 122,
     "MeanObserved": 0.43181001182262224,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.18056209502827084,
     "Fb": 0.8205727007599579,
     "Nmse": 1.8525060892388368,
     "Nad": 0.5012005937573267,
     "Fac2": 0.36065573770491804,
     "HitRate": 0.1721311475409836,
     "Mg": 2.399928443920321,
     "Vg": 9.74532037129418,
     "GeometricPairs": 117,
     "R": -0.2355288324845297
    },
    "halfExtent250.forward": {
     "Count": 122,
     "MeanObserved": 0.43181001182262224,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.26958291070729634,
     "Fb": 0.46258550921835384,
     "Nmse": 0.7649301771670082,
     "Nad": 0.3536322405882407,
     "Fac2": 0.45901639344262296,
     "HitRate": 0.1885245901639344,
     "Mg": 1.430559130423336,
     "Vg": 2.6570549898161997,
     "GeometricPairs": 122,
     "R": 0.010483695337128963
    },
    "halfExtent250.reversedWind": {
     "Count": 122,
     "MeanObserved": 0.43181001182262224,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.3841948169335764,
     "Fb": 0.11670321843958614,
     "Nmse": 0.3802484357902045,
     "Nad": 0.24474275751347507,
     "Fac2": 0.7049180327868853,
     "HitRate": 0.2786885245901639,
     "Mg": 0.9817437880894,
     "Vg": 1.812016219779101,
     "GeometricPairs": 117,
     "R": 0.3387050617701501
    }
   },
   "figures": [
    {
     "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/assets/figures/case-b-ml-agreement.png",
     "caption": "Case B, Eddy3D ML surrogate (Yel-2.0): measured against predicted pedestrian-height speed, with the 1:1 line and the factor-of-two band."
    }
   ],
   "pairs": {
    "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/api/cases/B/pairs/ml-surrogate.csv?v=eb9a9c3970e7",
    "path": "cases/B/pairs/ml-surrogate.csv",
    "media_type": "text/csv",
    "bytes": 8302,
    "sha256": "eb9a9c3970e76ef7ffc059038bd006708cb8295c1e3c12af83600c47c679bee8"
   },
   "pairs_columns": "set (the scored subset); x_tunnel, y_tunnel in m (case frame); x_scene, y_scene in m (the scaled scene the surrogate was given); observed_over_UH and predicted_over_UH, the speeds divided by U_H (Case E: by U at 15.9 m)",
   "reproduce": "Eddy3D fixture Outdoor.ML.Tests/TestAijSurrogateE2E; figure validation/plot_ml_surrogate.py",
   "source_file": "validation/results/caseB_ml.json",
   "source_url": "https://github.com/Eddy3D-Dev/AIJ-Data-Validation/blob/main/validation/results/caseB_ml.json",
   "cite": "Kikumoto, H., Okaze, T., Yoshie, R., Tachibana, T., Ishihara, T., Nonomura, Y., Kiyota, N., Kondo, H., Mochida, A., Tominaga, Y. (2026). Comprehensive Experimental Database for Validating CFD Simulations in Urban Wind Environment: Benchmark Cases Curated by the Architectural Institute of Japan. Japan Architectural Review 9(1), e70083. https://doi.org/10.1002/2475-8876.70083"
  }
 ],
 "grid_study": null,
 "note": null
}
