{
 "$schema": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/api/schemas/validation.schema.json",
 "schema_version": "2.6.0",
 "data_version": "7ee0afb7cec8197e7edde0e7c282c8e6e9670b7cef003e6aa218c5a536817f48",
 "license": "CC-BY-4.0",
 "case": "F",
 "title": "Case F — Shinjuku district",
 "status": "scored",
 "status_meaning": {
  "scored": "a validation run exists and its scores are in cases/{id}/validation.json",
  "running": "the solve is in progress; no scores yet",
  "pending": "not run yet",
  "not comparable": "the engine cannot produce the measured quantity at the measured location: OpenLB at 2 m on Cases C to E, where its empty-domain control misses the bar; the measurement behind it is on the Validation page"
 },
 "engines": [
  {
   "engine": "openfoam12-realizableKE",
   "status": "scored"
  },
  {
   "engine": "openlb",
   "status": "pending"
  },
  {
   "engine": "fluidx3d",
   "status": "pending"
  },
  {
   "engine": "ml-surrogate",
   "status": "pending"
  }
 ],
 "results": [
  {
   "run_id": "F.openfoam12-realizableKE.literal",
   "engine": "openfoam12-realizableKE",
   "configuration": "literal",
   "solver": "realizableKE",
   "numerics_level": 3,
   "scale": 800,
   "solved_time": null,
   "iterations": 2000,
   "points_measured": 46,
   "lateral_sign_applied_in_fixture": null,
   "recirculation_Lr_over_H": null,
   "quantity": "the thermistor's (tunnel) and the cup anemometer's (field) mean speed over U(500 m) against the model's |U| and sqrt(|U|^2 + 2k) over its own approach U(500 m) = 9.862 m/s (probed 1100 m upwind of the centre; the imposed U(500 m) is 10 m/s), at the 33 tunnel points (planes at 5, 9 and 20 m) and the 13 field observations of wind from NNW; frame literal",
   "normalisation": "the thermistor's (tunnel) and the cup anemometer's (field) mean speed over U(500 m), the benchmark's own ratio, against the model's |U| and sqrt(|U|^2 + 2k) over its own approach U(500 m) = 9.862 m/s (the imposed U(500 m) is 10 m/s); hit rate D = 0.25, W = 0.05 in those units; 33 tunnel points and 13 field observations of wind from NNW; FB is positive when the model is low",
   "notes": [
    "One direction of the tunnel's twelve was solved: wind from NNW, which with ENE has the most tunnel rows (33). The other eleven tunnel directions and the field's other fifteen were not run.",
    "Frame 'literal': the model is probed at the published z in the STL's frame. The readme says z is measured from the tunnel floor and the ground is z - 10 m, but the STL's own ground under all 13 points is 5 m, so the 5, 9 and 20 m planes are probed 10, 14 and 25 m above the STL's ground (height_above_stl_ground in the pairs). The other frame, 'agl' (the STL's ground plus 5, 9 and 20 m), is the other run of this case. The files do not say which frame the tunnel meant: the 9 m plane's √(|U|²+2k) scores R 0.93 and FB +0.04 in the literal frame and R 0.94 and FB +0.13 in the agl frame.",
    "Both sides are U/U(500 m): the tunnel's ratio is as published, the model's is over its own approach U(500 m) = 9.862 m/s, probed 1100 m upwind of the centre (0.986 of the imposed 10 m/s). Over the imposed 10 m/s the 9 m plane's √(|U|²+2k) scores R 0.93 and FB +0.05.",
    "The thermistor reads a scalar speed and so does the cup anemometer: the model is scored as |U|, which is the lower bound, and as √(|U|²+2k), the speed of a velocity with the modelled turbulent kinetic energy in all three components, which is the upper bracket (as in Cases C to E).",
    "The field is a year of 10-minute means above 5 m/s at a rooftop reference, over a sector 22.5° wide, at 3 to 11 m above ground; the standard deviation of the means behind each value is 0.075 to 0.15 of U(500 m), 0.20 to 0.78 of the value itself (the horizontal bars of the figure), and a RANS field is one steady state for one exact direction. The tunnel's 9 m column scored as a model of the field, point for point, gives R 0.93, FAC2 1.00, FB -0.01: the bar a model of the tunnel is not expected to clear.",
    "The field values of point 14 are the cleaned table's, realigned with the workbook: the published RS-FO_caseF.csv holds them shifted by one direction (clean/QUESTIONS.md QF1). The field scores here therefore differ from Eddy3D's own results file in the third decimal (√(|U|²+2k) in the literal frame: R 0.8729 here, 0.8731 there; in the agl frame 0.8893 and 0.8872); the tunnel scores are identical to it.",
    "The published STL is open along the rim of its 725 m disc (812 boundary edges, one shell, wound inward), which the canvas's pre-meshing pass cannot close (it removed 3 degenerate faces). The mesh has 2,143,488 cells and checkMesh fails one check (43 highly skew faces, maximum skewness 14.8, maximum non-orthogonality 64.8°), so the solve started on the hardened numerics of Eddy3D's mesh-quality tier.",
    "The solve ran to its 2000-iteration limit with the residualControl unmet (no 'solution converged' line); the initial residuals at the last iteration were U_x 1.0e-04, U_y 5.9e-05, U_z 2.6e-03, p 3.0e-05, epsilon 1.0e-03 and k 1.4e-04, and the log has 1,988 'bounding k' lines.",
    "The solved field correlates R 0.93 with the tunnel's 9 m column for the wind from NNW and R 0.08 with its column for the opposite wind, SSE (agl frame: 0.94 and 0.10). A RANS field knows no compass, so this supports reading the direction labels as the direction the wind comes from (clean/QUESTIONS.md QF9), at this one direction.",
    "The model's U/U(500 m) at the workbook's two rooftop anemometers (SMB 0.85 for |U|, KDD 0.45) is in the results file and not scored: the tunnel's anchors for them exist for the north and south tests only."
   ],
   "metric_meaning": {
    "Count": "number of measured points scored",
    "MeanObserved": "mean of the measured, normalised quantity",
    "MeanPredicted": "mean of the modelled, normalised quantity",
    "Fb": "fractional bias, 2 (mean_obs - mean_pred) / (mean_obs + mean_pred); positive = model low",
    "Nmse": "normalised mean square error",
    "Nad": "normalised absolute difference",
    "Fac2": "fraction of points within a factor of two (harsh near zero for sign-changing V and W)",
    "HitRate": "fraction of points within D = 0.25 relative or W = 0.05 U_H absolute",
    "Mg": "geometric mean bias",
    "Vg": "geometric variance",
    "GeometricPairs": "pairs with both values positive (used for Mg/Vg)",
    "R": "Pearson correlation coefficient",
    "null": "a metric that is undefined for the data (for example Mg and Vg when no pair has both values positive; Fb, Nmse and Nad of a signed velocity component of Case H or I whose observed and predicted means are not both positive)"
   },
   "headline": {
    "Tunnel, 9 m plane, √(|U|²+2k)": "tunnel.9m.rms",
    "Tunnel, 5 m plane, √(|U|²+2k)": "tunnel.5m.rms",
    "Tunnel, 20 m plane, √(|U|²+2k)": "tunnel.20m.rms",
    "Tunnel, all 33 points, √(|U|²+2k)": "tunnel.all.rms",
    "Tunnel, 9 m plane, |U|": "tunnel.9m.Umag",
    "Tunnel, 5 m plane, |U|": "tunnel.5m.Umag",
    "Tunnel, 20 m plane, |U|": "tunnel.20m.Umag",
    "Tunnel, all 33 points, |U|": "tunnel.all.Umag",
    "Field, √(|U|²+2k)": "field.rms",
    "Field, |U|": "field.Umag",
    "Tunnel, 9 m plane, √(|U|²+2k) over the imposed U(500 m) = 10 m/s": "tunnel.9m.rms.byImposedUR",
    "Tunnel's 9 m column as a model of the field (ceiling control)": "control.tunnelAsModelOfField",
    "Tunnel's SSE column, the opposite wind, against the solved NNW field (compass control)": "control.sense.opposite"
   },
   "scores": {
    "tunnel.5m.Umag": {
     "Count": 7,
     "MeanObserved": 0.2175714285714286,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.15973565499789505,
     "Fb": 0.306571363709408,
     "Nmse": 0.1328686581485395,
     "Nad": 0.15328568185470398,
     "Fac2": 0.8571428571428571,
     "HitRate": 0.5714285714285714,
     "Mg": 1.4217012656191008,
     "Vg": 1.1903405387140074,
     "GeometricPairs": 7,
     "R": 0.9883899693740864
    },
    "tunnel.5m.rms": {
     "Count": 7,
     "MeanObserved": 0.2175714285714286,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.191620502418501,
     "Fb": 0.12683987238040753,
     "Nmse": 0.05638864628700847,
     "Nad": 0.08297861744544464,
     "Fac2": 1.0,
     "HitRate": 1.0,
     "Mg": 1.0770235507873702,
     "Vg": 1.0237384532184264,
     "GeometricPairs": 7,
     "R": 0.995114129346732
    },
    "tunnel.9m.Umag": {
     "Count": 13,
     "MeanObserved": 0.26069230769230767,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.2278919451376105,
     "Fb": 0.1342669656859177,
     "Nmse": 0.06639712690484038,
     "Nad": 0.10706164108961586,
     "Fac2": 1.0,
     "HitRate": 0.6153846153846154,
     "Mg": 1.165876889874821,
     "Vg": 1.0935273244358126,
     "GeometricPairs": 13,
     "R": 0.9283347543817234
    },
    "tunnel.9m.rms": {
     "Count": 13,
     "MeanObserved": 0.26069230769230767,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.2514960536855189,
     "Fb": 0.03590965629148663,
     "Nmse": 0.04186167510127933,
     "Nad": 0.08478801658430857,
     "Fac2": 1.0,
     "HitRate": 0.8461538461538461,
     "Mg": 1.0077079609889026,
     "Vg": 1.0531513847745098,
     "GeometricPairs": 13,
     "R": 0.9348280677027181
    },
    "tunnel.20m.Umag": {
     "Count": 13,
     "MeanObserved": 0.3545384615384615,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.3169075340286296,
     "Fb": 0.11208921568755366,
     "Nmse": 0.06718747489222021,
     "Nad": 0.10603935287800936,
     "Fac2": 0.9230769230769231,
     "HitRate": 0.6923076923076923,
     "Mg": 1.1016473510976414,
     "Vg": 1.0852902093262176,
     "GeometricPairs": 13,
     "R": 0.7876930118356161
    },
    "tunnel.20m.rms": {
     "Count": 13,
     "MeanObserved": 0.3545384615384615,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.33020829977073285,
     "Fb": 0.07106324014212459,
     "Nmse": 0.05566922068694731,
     "Nad": 0.0930521837587111,
     "Fac2": 0.9230769230769231,
     "HitRate": 0.7692307692307693,
     "Mg": 1.0480235943789997,
     "Vg": 1.0718998777673439,
     "GeometricPairs": 13,
     "R": 0.7957548848765235
    },
    "tunnel.all.Umag": {
     "Count": 33,
     "MeanObserved": 0.28851515151515156,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.2485012973983754,
     "Fb": 0.14902282489756433,
     "Nmse": 0.07681380186193747,
     "Nad": 0.11344716068189085,
     "Fac2": 0.9393939393939394,
     "HitRate": 0.6363636363636364,
     "Mg": 1.189140712934519,
     "Vg": 1.1100714186977065,
     "GeometricPairs": 33,
     "R": 0.9064806470762246
    },
    "tunnel.all.rms": {
     "Count": 33,
     "MeanObserved": 0.28851515151515156,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.26980303369275094,
     "Fb": 0.06703030034901242,
     "Nmse": 0.05327812310560711,
     "Nad": 0.08849951274922785,
     "Fac2": 0.9696969696969697,
     "HitRate": 0.8484848484848485,
     "Mg": 1.037944846974946,
     "Vg": 1.0541447631033933,
     "GeometricPairs": 33,
     "R": 0.9123430058058702
    },
    "field.Umag": {
     "Count": 13,
     "MeanObserved": 0.2569230769230769,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.22651952038110276,
     "Fb": 0.12577938605953828,
     "Nmse": 0.11238652338227882,
     "Nad": 0.14288313637069616,
     "Fac2": 1.0,
     "HitRate": 0.3076923076923077,
     "Mg": 1.1637396124389778,
     "Vg": 1.114453476496436,
     "GeometricPairs": 13,
     "R": 0.8601927093746893
    },
    "field.rms": {
     "Count": 13,
     "MeanObserved": 0.2569230769230769,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.25002294455218227,
     "Fb": 0.027222355353789487,
     "Nmse": 0.08015504590902045,
     "Nad": 0.11159645165880135,
     "Fac2": 1.0,
     "HitRate": 0.7692307692307693,
     "Mg": 1.008856926537466,
     "Vg": 1.058153543727913,
     "GeometricPairs": 13,
     "R": 0.8729266100461673
    },
    "tunnel.9m.rms.byImposedUR": {
     "Count": 13,
     "MeanObserved": 0.26069230769230767,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.2480238740187313,
     "Fb": 0.04980550699593155,
     "Nmse": 0.04404973126231644,
     "Nad": 0.0860482174386605,
     "Fac2": 1.0,
     "HitRate": 0.8461538461538461,
     "Mg": 1.021815244435098,
     "Vg": 1.0535798607836953,
     "GeometricPairs": 13,
     "R": 0.9348280677027181
    },
    "control.tunnelAsModelOfField": {
     "Count": 13,
     "MeanObserved": 0.2569230769230769,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.26069230769230767,
     "Fb": -0.014563828206271277,
     "Nmse": 0.042433074246903055,
     "Nad": 0.08158716005349977,
     "Fac2": 1.0,
     "HitRate": 0.6923076923076923,
     "Mg": 0.9979517645267864,
     "Vg": 1.0584386877921308,
     "GeometricPairs": 13,
     "R": 0.9329815921497503
    },
    "control.sense.opposite": {
     "Count": 13,
     "MeanObserved": 0.34969230769230764,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.2514960536855189,
     "Fb": 0.3266738357400625,
     "Nmse": 0.46360282857558044,
     "Nad": 0.31168430651903145,
     "Fac2": 0.6153846153846154,
     "HitRate": 0.07692307692307693,
     "Mg": 1.447331728271253,
     "Vg": 1.696852474868538,
     "GeometricPairs": 13,
     "R": 0.07712463588818777
    }
   },
   "figures": [
    {
     "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/assets/figures/case-f-layout.png",
     "caption": "Case F, measurement points: A tunnel plane 5 m above ground; B tunnel plane 9 m above ground; C tunnel plane 20 m above ground; D field cup anemometers, 3 to 11 m above ground. Positions in metres, full scale. SMB and KDD: the reference buildings. The field anemometers stand at the places of the tunnel points."
    },
    {
     "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/assets/figures/case-f-openfoam-agreement.png",
     "caption": "Case F, OpenFOAM 12 (realizable k-ε), wind from NNW: the tunnel's and the field's U/U(500 m) against the modelled √(|U|²+2k) (filled) and |U| (hollow) over the model's own U(500 m), in two vertical frames (top: the published z in the STL's frame; bottom: the STL's ground plus the instrument height), for the 9 m plane, all 33 tunnel points (planes at 5, 9 and 20 m) and the 13 field observations (bars: the standard deviation of the 10-minute means). Dots take the colour of the group of points they belong to: the letters and colours of the layout figure of the case."
    },
    {
     "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/assets/figures/case-f-openfoam-bias-map.png",
     "caption": "Case F, OpenFOAM 12, wind from NNW: log₂(model / tunnel) of the scalar speed at the tunnel's 13 points of the 9 m plane on the plan of the district (full-scale metres, north up; the arrow is the wind), in the two vertical frames."
    },
    {
     "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/assets/figures/case-f-openfoam-field-plan.png",
     "caption": "Case F, OpenFOAM 12: the solved field on 9 m above the ground (z = 14 m), wind from NNW; a and b show the component along the wind. a: u; b: u with iso-lines every 0.1 and the edge of the reversed flow (u = 0) dashed; c: the in-plane speed with streamlines. Each dot is a measured point, coloured by its measured value on the panel's scale."
    }
   ],
   "pairs": {
    "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/api/cases/F/pairs/openfoam12-realizableKE.csv?v=e81e010859e6",
    "path": "cases/F/pairs/openfoam12-realizableKE.csv",
    "media_type": "text/csv",
    "bytes": 9531,
    "sha256": "e81e010859e6d51666aab0260a6c00b259faed3e119db44dbb1fa9faeacfbd0e"
   },
   "pairs_columns": "frame (literal or agl: the two runs share this file), source (tunnel: the thermistor at 5, 9 and 20 m; field: the cup anemometers), plane_m (the instrument height above ground by the readme's rule: 5, 9 or 20 for the tunnel, 3 to 11 for the field), point_id (the table's); x and y in m and z_published, the height above the tunnel floor in m, full scale (+x east, +y north); z_probe, the height the model was probed at (the published z in the literal frame; the STL's own ground under the point plus plane_m in the agl frame) and height_above_stl_ground, the probe's height above that ground; observed, the cleaned table's U/U(500 m) for wind from NNW, and observed_sd, the standard deviation of the 10-minute means behind a field value; observed_sse, the tunnel's 9 m value for the opposite wind (SSE) at the same point, for the compass control; Umag_model and rms_model, the modelled |U| and sqrt(|U|^2 + 2k) over the model's own approach U(500 m) (U500 in the results file); k_model, k in m^2/s^2",
   "reproduce": "Eddy3D fixture Eddy3DCli.Tests/Validation/TestAijCaseFContainerE2E (EDDY3D_AIJ_F_DIRECTIONS=NNW, the default) (Shinjuku district, 1:800, wind from NNW, frame literal; OpenFOAM 12 realizable k-ε, numerics level 3, 2000 iterations, 2,143,488 cells, solved 2026-10-18); figures validation/plot_cases_fm_openfoam.py; scores recomputed from the pairs by validation/dispersion_metrics.py; the SHA-256 of every file the snapshot was read from is in its results file, under `sources`",
   "source_file": "validation/results/caseF_openfoam12_realizableKE_literal.json",
   "source_url": "https://github.com/Eddy3D-Dev/AIJ-Data-Validation/blob/main/validation/results/caseF_openfoam12_realizableKE_literal.json",
   "cite": "Kikumoto, H., Okaze, T., Yoshie, R., Tachibana, T., Ishihara, T., Nonomura, Y., Kiyota, N., Kondo, H., Mochida, A., Tominaga, Y. (2026). Comprehensive Experimental Database for Validating CFD Simulations in Urban Wind Environment: Benchmark Cases Curated by the Architectural Institute of Japan. Japan Architectural Review 9(1), e70083. https://doi.org/10.1002/2475-8876.70083"
  },
  {
   "run_id": "F.openfoam12-realizableKE.agl",
   "engine": "openfoam12-realizableKE",
   "configuration": "agl",
   "solver": "realizableKE",
   "numerics_level": 3,
   "scale": 800,
   "solved_time": null,
   "iterations": 2000,
   "points_measured": 46,
   "lateral_sign_applied_in_fixture": null,
   "recirculation_Lr_over_H": null,
   "quantity": "the thermistor's (tunnel) and the cup anemometer's (field) mean speed over U(500 m) against the model's |U| and sqrt(|U|^2 + 2k) over its own approach U(500 m) = 9.862 m/s (probed 1100 m upwind of the centre; the imposed U(500 m) is 10 m/s), at the 33 tunnel points (planes at 5, 9 and 20 m) and the 13 field observations of wind from NNW; frame agl",
   "normalisation": "the thermistor's (tunnel) and the cup anemometer's (field) mean speed over U(500 m), the benchmark's own ratio, against the model's |U| and sqrt(|U|^2 + 2k) over its own approach U(500 m) = 9.862 m/s (the imposed U(500 m) is 10 m/s); hit rate D = 0.25, W = 0.05 in those units; 33 tunnel points and 13 field observations of wind from NNW; FB is positive when the model is low",
   "notes": [
    "One direction of the tunnel's twelve was solved: wind from NNW, which with ENE has the most tunnel rows (33). The other eleven tunnel directions and the field's other fifteen were not run.",
    "Frame 'agl': the model is probed at the STL's own ground under each point plus the instrument height (5, 9 and 20 m for the tunnel, 3 to 11 m for the field). The readme says z is measured from the tunnel floor and the ground is z - 10 m, but the STL's ground under all 13 points is 5 m, so the published z would sit 5 m higher; that frame is the other run of this case, 'literal'. The files do not say which frame the tunnel meant: the 9 m plane's √(|U|²+2k) scores R 0.93 and FB +0.04 in the literal frame and R 0.94 and FB +0.13 in the agl frame.",
    "At the 4 m surface cells of the mesh the lowest probes of this frame (the 7 points of the 5 m plane, 1.25 cells above the ground, and the field's point at 3 m) sit in the first cell, where the point interpolation is pulled toward the wall's zero.",
    "Both sides are U/U(500 m): the tunnel's ratio is as published, the model's is over its own approach U(500 m) = 9.862 m/s, probed 1100 m upwind of the centre (0.986 of the imposed 10 m/s). Over the imposed 10 m/s the 9 m plane's √(|U|²+2k) scores R 0.94 and FB +0.14.",
    "The thermistor reads a scalar speed and so does the cup anemometer: the model is scored as |U|, which is the lower bound, and as √(|U|²+2k), the speed of a velocity with the modelled turbulent kinetic energy in all three components, which is the upper bracket (as in Cases C to E).",
    "The field is a year of 10-minute means above 5 m/s at a rooftop reference, over a sector 22.5° wide, at 3 to 11 m above ground; the standard deviation of the means behind each value is 0.075 to 0.15 of U(500 m), 0.20 to 0.78 of the value itself (the horizontal bars of the figure), and a RANS field is one steady state for one exact direction. The tunnel's 9 m column scored as a model of the field, point for point, gives R 0.93, FAC2 1.00, FB -0.01: the bar a model of the tunnel is not expected to clear.",
    "The field values of point 14 are the cleaned table's, realigned with the workbook: the published RS-FO_caseF.csv holds them shifted by one direction (clean/QUESTIONS.md QF1). The field scores here therefore differ from Eddy3D's own results file in the third decimal (√(|U|²+2k) in the literal frame: R 0.8729 here, 0.8731 there; in the agl frame 0.8893 and 0.8872); the tunnel scores are identical to it.",
    "The published STL is open along the rim of its 725 m disc (812 boundary edges, one shell, wound inward), which the canvas's pre-meshing pass cannot close (it removed 3 degenerate faces). The mesh has 2,143,488 cells and checkMesh fails one check (43 highly skew faces, maximum skewness 14.8, maximum non-orthogonality 64.8°), so the solve started on the hardened numerics of Eddy3D's mesh-quality tier.",
    "The solve ran to its 2000-iteration limit with the residualControl unmet (no 'solution converged' line); the initial residuals at the last iteration were U_x 1.0e-04, U_y 5.9e-05, U_z 2.6e-03, p 3.0e-05, epsilon 1.0e-03 and k 1.4e-04, and the log has 1,988 'bounding k' lines.",
    "The solved field correlates R 0.93 with the tunnel's 9 m column for the wind from NNW and R 0.08 with its column for the opposite wind, SSE (agl frame: 0.94 and 0.10). A RANS field knows no compass, so this supports reading the direction labels as the direction the wind comes from (clean/QUESTIONS.md QF9), at this one direction.",
    "The model's U/U(500 m) at the workbook's two rooftop anemometers (SMB 0.85 for |U|, KDD 0.45) is in the results file and not scored: the tunnel's anchors for them exist for the north and south tests only."
   ],
   "metric_meaning": {
    "Count": "number of measured points scored",
    "MeanObserved": "mean of the measured, normalised quantity",
    "MeanPredicted": "mean of the modelled, normalised quantity",
    "Fb": "fractional bias, 2 (mean_obs - mean_pred) / (mean_obs + mean_pred); positive = model low",
    "Nmse": "normalised mean square error",
    "Nad": "normalised absolute difference",
    "Fac2": "fraction of points within a factor of two (harsh near zero for sign-changing V and W)",
    "HitRate": "fraction of points within D = 0.25 relative or W = 0.05 U_H absolute",
    "Mg": "geometric mean bias",
    "Vg": "geometric variance",
    "GeometricPairs": "pairs with both values positive (used for Mg/Vg)",
    "R": "Pearson correlation coefficient",
    "null": "a metric that is undefined for the data (for example Mg and Vg when no pair has both values positive; Fb, Nmse and Nad of a signed velocity component of Case H or I whose observed and predicted means are not both positive)"
   },
   "headline": {
    "Tunnel, 9 m plane, √(|U|²+2k)": "tunnel.9m.rms",
    "Tunnel, 5 m plane, √(|U|²+2k)": "tunnel.5m.rms",
    "Tunnel, 20 m plane, √(|U|²+2k)": "tunnel.20m.rms",
    "Tunnel, all 33 points, √(|U|²+2k)": "tunnel.all.rms",
    "Tunnel, 9 m plane, |U|": "tunnel.9m.Umag",
    "Tunnel, 5 m plane, |U|": "tunnel.5m.Umag",
    "Tunnel, 20 m plane, |U|": "tunnel.20m.Umag",
    "Tunnel, all 33 points, |U|": "tunnel.all.Umag",
    "Field, √(|U|²+2k)": "field.rms",
    "Field, |U|": "field.Umag",
    "Tunnel, 9 m plane, √(|U|²+2k) over the imposed U(500 m) = 10 m/s": "tunnel.9m.rms.byImposedUR",
    "Tunnel's 9 m column as a model of the field (ceiling control)": "control.tunnelAsModelOfField",
    "Tunnel's SSE column, the opposite wind, against the solved NNW field (compass control)": "control.sense.opposite"
   },
   "scores": {
    "tunnel.5m.Umag": {
     "Count": 7,
     "MeanObserved": 0.2175714285714286,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.16772834574273013,
     "Fb": 0.25872365441905676,
     "Nmse": 0.15957226153764925,
     "Nad": 0.1565450306750926,
     "Fac2": 0.8571428571428571,
     "HitRate": 0.5714285714285714,
     "Mg": 1.3500250600237222,
     "Vg": 1.3299458114232483,
     "GeometricPairs": 7,
     "R": 0.9234998944298768
    },
    "tunnel.5m.rms": {
     "Count": 7,
     "MeanObserved": 0.2175714285714286,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.19131010465141823,
     "Fb": 0.12845443868797835,
     "Nmse": 0.10351019254694103,
     "Nad": 0.14319844825067296,
     "Fac2": 1.0,
     "HitRate": 0.5714285714285714,
     "Mg": 1.1039861088382819,
     "Vg": 1.1355157935978595,
     "GeometricPairs": 7,
     "R": 0.9183220048763334
    },
    "tunnel.9m.Umag": {
     "Count": 13,
     "MeanObserved": 0.26069230769230767,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.20447977592672972,
     "Fb": 0.24168488929191373,
     "Nmse": 0.1080866655467555,
     "Nad": 0.1328075385242056,
     "Fac2": 0.9230769230769231,
     "HitRate": 0.5384615384615384,
     "Mg": 1.3472662533155513,
     "Vg": 1.2085308059019793,
     "GeometricPairs": 13,
     "R": 0.935184900834015
    },
    "tunnel.9m.rms": {
     "Count": 13,
     "MeanObserved": 0.26069230769230767,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.22988887797868307,
     "Fb": 0.1255793357484483,
     "Nmse": 0.055388694321112215,
     "Nad": 0.09932261532141698,
     "Fac2": 1.0,
     "HitRate": 0.7692307692307693,
     "Mg": 1.114813932622903,
     "Vg": 1.066471372142425,
     "GeometricPairs": 13,
     "R": 0.9447596376333688
    },
    "tunnel.20m.Umag": {
     "Count": 13,
     "MeanObserved": 0.3545384615384615,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.27048251636144544,
     "Fb": 0.26896999668538196,
     "Nmse": 0.1380887196041659,
     "Nad": 0.16134460905689998,
     "Fac2": 0.8461538461538461,
     "HitRate": 0.3076923076923077,
     "Mg": 1.3517574256064273,
     "Vg": 1.2153813202646147,
     "GeometricPairs": 13,
     "R": 0.8010409588746911
    },
    "tunnel.20m.rms": {
     "Count": 13,
     "MeanObserved": 0.3545384615384615,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.28769590973362774,
     "Fb": 0.2081562581972594,
     "Nmse": 0.10064897708470182,
     "Nad": 0.1350156667235395,
     "Fac2": 1.0,
     "HitRate": 0.46153846153846156,
     "Mg": 1.2450789018642539,
     "Vg": 1.1417520138423165,
     "GeometricPairs": 13,
     "R": 0.8069222117937329
    },
    "tunnel.all.Umag": {
     "Count": 33,
     "MeanObserved": 0.28851515151515156,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.22268509757410268,
     "Fb": 0.25755094626158964,
     "Nmse": 0.13574935930322907,
     "Nad": 0.15034759216513519,
     "Fac2": 0.8787878787878788,
     "HitRate": 0.45454545454545453,
     "Mg": 1.3496192159881897,
     "Vg": 1.2360725973150704,
     "GeometricPairs": 33,
     "R": 0.8943205110753206
    },
    "tunnel.all.rms": {
     "Count": 33,
     "MeanObserved": 0.28851515151515156,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.24447796887333237,
     "Fb": 0.16524484447274557,
     "Nmse": 0.0888319241137273,
     "Nad": 0.12340519817524592,
     "Fac2": 1.0,
     "HitRate": 0.6060606060606061,
     "Mg": 1.162010819091818,
     "Vg": 1.1101910716181702,
     "GeometricPairs": 33,
     "R": 0.8980306722504324
    },
    "field.Umag": {
     "Count": 13,
     "MeanObserved": 0.2569230769230769,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.19668898471495,
     "Fb": 0.2655753552523146,
     "Nmse": 0.17910865286659333,
     "Nad": 0.1711356737930761,
     "Fac2": 0.8461538461538461,
     "HitRate": 0.3076923076923077,
     "Mg": 1.3668220160891196,
     "Vg": 1.2730248906732562,
     "GeometricPairs": 13,
     "R": 0.8659879787925158
    },
    "field.rms": {
     "Count": 13,
     "MeanObserved": 0.2569230769230769,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.22173474576955338,
     "Fb": 0.1470291698381777,
     "Nmse": 0.10738890107564514,
     "Nad": 0.13073989434574193,
     "Fac2": 1.0,
     "HitRate": 0.6923076923076923,
     "Mg": 1.1342254412155084,
     "Vg": 1.0894129048679349,
     "GeometricPairs": 13,
     "R": 0.8892758261161317
    },
    "tunnel.9m.rms.byImposedUR": {
     "Count": 13,
     "MeanObserved": 0.26069230769230767,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.2267150091404216,
     "Fb": 0.13942055188123723,
     "Nmse": 0.060391271611213514,
     "Nad": 0.10329341784936087,
     "Fac2": 1.0,
     "HitRate": 0.6923076923076923,
     "Mg": 1.1304206329231026,
     "Vg": 1.0699058995435735,
     "GeometricPairs": 13,
     "R": 0.9447596376333687
    },
    "control.tunnelAsModelOfField": {
     "Count": 13,
     "MeanObserved": 0.2569230769230769,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.26069230769230767,
     "Fb": -0.014563828206271277,
     "Nmse": 0.042433074246903055,
     "Nad": 0.08158716005349977,
     "Fac2": 1.0,
     "HitRate": 0.6923076923076923,
     "Mg": 0.9979517645267864,
     "Vg": 1.0584386877921308,
     "GeometricPairs": 13,
     "R": 0.9329815921497503
    },
    "control.sense.opposite": {
     "Count": 13,
     "MeanObserved": 0.34969230769230764,
     "MeanPredicted": 0.22988887797868307,
     "Fb": 0.41341379836174685,
     "Nmse": 0.5451352369825203,
     "Nad": 0.3336538516486561,
     "Fac2": 0.38461538461538464,
     "HitRate": 0.0,
     "Mg": 1.6011638671789223,
     "Vg": 1.8887705331146554,
     "GeometricPairs": 13,
     "R": 0.10187766908062999
    }
   },
   "figures": [
    {
     "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/assets/figures/case-f-layout.png",
     "caption": "Case F, measurement points: A tunnel plane 5 m above ground; B tunnel plane 9 m above ground; C tunnel plane 20 m above ground; D field cup anemometers, 3 to 11 m above ground. Positions in metres, full scale. SMB and KDD: the reference buildings. The field anemometers stand at the places of the tunnel points."
    },
    {
     "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/assets/figures/case-f-openfoam-agreement.png",
     "caption": "Case F, OpenFOAM 12 (realizable k-ε), wind from NNW: the tunnel's and the field's U/U(500 m) against the modelled √(|U|²+2k) (filled) and |U| (hollow) over the model's own U(500 m), in two vertical frames (top: the published z in the STL's frame; bottom: the STL's ground plus the instrument height), for the 9 m plane, all 33 tunnel points (planes at 5, 9 and 20 m) and the 13 field observations (bars: the standard deviation of the 10-minute means). Dots take the colour of the group of points they belong to: the letters and colours of the layout figure of the case."
    },
    {
     "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/assets/figures/case-f-openfoam-bias-map.png",
     "caption": "Case F, OpenFOAM 12, wind from NNW: log₂(model / tunnel) of the scalar speed at the tunnel's 13 points of the 9 m plane on the plan of the district (full-scale metres, north up; the arrow is the wind), in the two vertical frames."
    },
    {
     "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/assets/figures/case-f-openfoam-field-plan.png",
     "caption": "Case F, OpenFOAM 12: the solved field on 9 m above the ground (z = 14 m), wind from NNW; a and b show the component along the wind. a: u; b: u with iso-lines every 0.1 and the edge of the reversed flow (u = 0) dashed; c: the in-plane speed with streamlines. Each dot is a measured point, coloured by its measured value on the panel's scale."
    }
   ],
   "pairs": {
    "url": "https://aij.eddy3d.com/api/cases/F/pairs/openfoam12-realizableKE.csv?v=e81e010859e6",
    "path": "cases/F/pairs/openfoam12-realizableKE.csv",
    "media_type": "text/csv",
    "bytes": 9531,
    "sha256": "e81e010859e6d51666aab0260a6c00b259faed3e119db44dbb1fa9faeacfbd0e"
   },
   "pairs_columns": "frame (literal or agl: the two runs share this file), source (tunnel: the thermistor at 5, 9 and 20 m; field: the cup anemometers), plane_m (the instrument height above ground by the readme's rule: 5, 9 or 20 for the tunnel, 3 to 11 for the field), point_id (the table's); x and y in m and z_published, the height above the tunnel floor in m, full scale (+x east, +y north); z_probe, the height the model was probed at (the published z in the literal frame; the STL's own ground under the point plus plane_m in the agl frame) and height_above_stl_ground, the probe's height above that ground; observed, the cleaned table's U/U(500 m) for wind from NNW, and observed_sd, the standard deviation of the 10-minute means behind a field value; observed_sse, the tunnel's 9 m value for the opposite wind (SSE) at the same point, for the compass control; Umag_model and rms_model, the modelled |U| and sqrt(|U|^2 + 2k) over the model's own approach U(500 m) (U500 in the results file); k_model, k in m^2/s^2",
   "reproduce": "Eddy3D fixture Eddy3DCli.Tests/Validation/TestAijCaseFContainerE2E (EDDY3D_AIJ_F_DIRECTIONS=NNW, the default) (Shinjuku district, 1:800, wind from NNW, frame agl; OpenFOAM 12 realizable k-ε, numerics level 3, 2000 iterations, 2,143,488 cells, solved 2026-10-18); figures validation/plot_cases_fm_openfoam.py; scores recomputed from the pairs by validation/dispersion_metrics.py; the SHA-256 of every file the snapshot was read from is in its results file, under `sources`",
   "source_file": "validation/results/caseF_openfoam12_realizableKE_agl.json",
   "source_url": "https://github.com/Eddy3D-Dev/AIJ-Data-Validation/blob/main/validation/results/caseF_openfoam12_realizableKE_agl.json",
   "cite": "Kikumoto, H., Okaze, T., Yoshie, R., Tachibana, T., Ishihara, T., Nonomura, Y., Kiyota, N., Kondo, H., Mochida, A., Tominaga, Y. (2026). Comprehensive Experimental Database for Validating CFD Simulations in Urban Wind Environment: Benchmark Cases Curated by the Architectural Institute of Japan. Japan Architectural Review 9(1), e70083. https://doi.org/10.1002/2475-8876.70083"
  }
 ],
 "grid_study": null,
 "note": null
}
